Showing posts with label foreign film. Show all posts
Showing posts with label foreign film. Show all posts

Sunday, February 28, 2016

Genre and Social Consciousness in West African Cinema



          When people search for political films or films that comment on culture they typically seek out dramas and or art house films. Why are art house films and foreign films typically the bastion of academics and intellectuals? It seems counterintuitive to use something esoteric to highlight an issue or cause social change. One of the great things about visual storytelling and movies in particular are their accessibility as both an art form and communication tool. Aside from the oral tradition for the majority of human history consuming forms of storytelling like theatre and the written word was the privilege of the wealthy and elite. Today storytelling especially visual storytelling is consumed by the masses. Despite not being highly literate people today are more sophisticated consumers of story and narrative than ever before. For film theorist West African cinema is fertile ground to explore this intersection.
          Despite melodrama and comedy being considered “B” genres they are important genres both as art and cultural/political influence. The accessibility of cinema makes it an ideal to disseminating information to the masses. This is one of the reasons that German and Italian fascists were film enthusiasts.  Nollywood also unfairly faces a similar stigma as the comedy and melodrama genres. “Academic criticism has often ignored, condescended to, or denounced the videos because they did not seem politically serious.” (Haynes 2006). Coincidently melodrama and comedy are prominent genres in Nollywood cinema.
          Melodrama is a word that is used often in American vernacular but similar to the term found footage melodrama’s pop usage is often different from its academic definition. For the purposes of this paper is melodrama is a narrative work characterized by extravagant theatricality and by the predominance of plot and physical action over characterization. TV has a long history in Nigeria. Melodrama and comedy have a long history in television most commonly sitcoms and soap operas. Nigeria also has a long history of Spanish language soap operas called telenovelas. This history makes comedy and melodrama ideal genres for the Nigerian film industry.
          Using genres that are widely consumed by and associated with television is important to Nollywood’s appeal. Nollywood films are produced with home viewing in mind. Nollywood films are typically distributed via home viewing mediums like VHS, DVD, and VCD.  Despite Nollywood not having a wide theatrical release in the major West African movie theatre chains it remains an influential movement in West African cinema. “… advances in the industry of motion picture making could only be measured by the control over the means of production that a filmmaker secured, not by a film’s financial triumph.” (Genova 2013). Nollywood capitalizing on the home video market and direct to market distribution helped lead to an African owned movie industry. Before Nollywood much of West Africa’s film industry was dependent on overseas financing largely from Western Europe and North America. This reflected the neo colonialism that arose in post colonial West Africa. Nollywood being an African owned film industry with African filmmakers and African actors gives Nollywood an important role to play in decolonization.
          Not all West African Cinema is a Nollywood film but Nollywood films are West African cinema. Two large distinctions in West African cinema are African art house films verses Nollywood. Both can be political but the two differ greatly in esthetics, distribution, and cinematic grammar. Nollywood has a DIY esthetic utilizing video in its infancy before moving onto digital formats with better resolution and overall visual quality. Nollywood films also have a unique cinematic grammar ignoring things like continuity editing. Narratively Nollywood again breaks from convention. Films have longer run times then the average feature length motion picture produced in the west. In addition plot points will often be repeated. The repetition is important because Nollywood films are produced with home consumption in mind and take into account the viewer maybe doing household chores. Nollywood films are distributed mainly direct to video and African art house cinema is typically distributed via the festival circuit and screened in art house theatres in Europe and America.
          Despite African art house cinema often having overt political statements these films are rarely screened in Africa. For this very practical reason Nollywood films are a much more effective way of reaching African audiences. Despite this fact Nollywood’s esthetics and cinematic grammar are often used to be dismissive and reductionist towards Nollywood these are some of the factors that make Nollywood film’s more accessible in both viewership and production.
          Nollywood is not just a regional movie industry. Nollywood’s output makes it one of the largest movie industries in the world and similar to other large movie industries like Hollywood and Daliwood Nollywood exports a large volume of product. This export of a West African art form produced and distributed by Africans is influential in the pan African movement. Both during colonialism and post colonialism Africa has experienced a Diaspora. Africans and African culture spans the globe to places like the U.K., France, The Caribbean, The United States, and Canada to name but a few. The Nollywood film The Messenger (2013) is a comedy that can have a political reading of both the text and subtext of the film. In The Messenger (2013) everyone speaks Igbo even white Londoners and traditional Nigerian food and beer is prevalent. Instead of the colonial gaze depicting Africa we now have the Nigerian gaze depicting London. Themes associated with the pan Africa movement, colonialism, and the Diaspora is prevalent in the accessible and enjoyable comedy.
          In many ways Nollywood clashes with the ethos of third cinema. Third cinema is a cinematic movement that essentially states colonialism and neo colonialism are such critical issues that filmmakers need to ignore any commercial or mass appeal considerations in lieu of communicating serious political messages. In principle I agree with third cinema however in practical application Nollywood is a much more effective tool for communicating to mass audiences. The old adage sung by Marry Poppins is still true, “A spoonful of sugar helps the medicine go down.” (Andrews 1964). 
          Aside from the inaccessibility of African art films to the African masses in terms of consumption it is even less accessible in terms of the means of production due to the high costs related to equipment and materials necessary to make feature length films with traditional Hollywood production values. “The videos established themselves as an essential medium through which Nigeria represented itself to itself during the 1990’s…” (Haynes 2006). VHS & digital technology has played a huge role democratizing the craft of filmmaking & cinema culture globally and nowhere has the impact been as great as Nollywood.
          VHS and digital technology have caused great changes in both filmmaking and consumption of cinema in the twenty first century. It has made visual storytelling a much more accessible art form in terms of consumption and production. VHS is much cheaper then film stock and does not need to be processed before it can be edited. Also, VHS is much cheaper and easier to dub then 35mm film. This fact combined with the long history and popularity of television in Nigeria made this an ideal way to disseminate movies. These video movies were rarely if ever screened in Nigeria in the mainstream movie theatres. The screens in those theatres screened mostly foreign blockbuster films. This led to the rise of the video parlor. In Nollywood Africans are not only the filmmakers and talent they now control distribution and exhibition as well.
          If one’s goal is decolonization it is important to control the means of production and distribution. For years countries rich with natural resources saw the majority of its citizens live in poverty. That is because the general populace had no ownership in production or distribution there by not sharing in the win fall of profits when these raw materials were processed and exported. Nollywood as opposed to African art films are far more effective in combating colonization and promoting decolonization. African art films may have powerful messages but they often times receive funding from European and North American investors and production companies. This relationship helps perpetuate neo colonialism despite often times the best of intentions of both the filmmaker and investors.
          An important part of decolonization that art and pop culture play a role in is self representation. “Nigerian video films are the leading form of Nigerian popular culture.” (Haynes 2006). Africans controlling how stories about Africa and Africans are portrayed impact cultural perception. Films like Osufia in London (2003) are African films that do not have the colonial gaze while also entertaining mainstream audiences with its comedy that is both broad and accessible while also being political.
          Osufia in London (2003) is a comedy that appears to be a classic fish out of water story and is certainly not an African art film but that doesn’t mean it is not a political film. The political aspect of this story is instead of the audience laughing at Osufia for being a stranger in a strange land and ignorant of the customs the British are exposed and lampooned for both their greed and absurdity. Osufia is triumphant despite being underestimated by those who seek to defraud him.
          The Messenger (2013), Moolaade (2004), Ceddo (1977), Osufia in London (2003), Maami (2011) are all valid works of art despite some being African art films and others being Nollywood films or some being comedies and other melodramas. Separating films by “high” art and “low” art is reductionist and causes an incomplete study of film theory. Nollywood as a movement has many unique qualities such as its DIY esthetic and ignoring modern contemporary cinematic grammar. However in light of the issues stemming from colonization and neocolonialism Nollywood’s contributions to the craft of filmmaking are not as important as its ability to reach the average person. A film industry where Africans own, produce, perform in, distribute, and exhibit their own motion pictures is important in an area of the world victimized by colonialism and neocolonialism. Nollywood illustrates the triumph of independent film culture in Nigeria as both a powerful art form for expression but a vehicle for political and social change.



Works Cited

Mary Poppins. Directed by Robert Stevenson. Performed by Julie Andrews. 1964.
The Messenger. Directed by Obi Emelonye. 2013.
Genova, James E. Cinema And Development In West Africa. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2013.
Haynes, Jonathan. "Political Critique In Nigerian Video Films." African Affairs, 2006: 511-533.
Maami. Directed by Tunde Kelani. 2011.
Osuofia In London. Directed by Kingsley Ogoro. 2003.
Ceddo. Directed by Ousmane Sembene. 1977.
Moolaade. Directed by Ousmane Sembene. 2004.

Monday, February 8, 2016

A review of Brother (1997)





            Brother (1997) is a Russian crime thriller that depicts a country at a crossroads after the fall of the Soviet Union. The film is set in early ninties St. Petersburg, a young man named Danila Bagrov played by the late Sergei Bodrov Jr. has recently been released from military service and returns to his mother’s home. Danila is from an area with little prospects so his mother sends him to St. Petersburg to stay with his older brother. Once Danila reaches St. Petersburg the film truly begins. It turns out Danila’s brother is a hit man for the thriving Russian mafia and he can put Danila’s military skills to good use. Brother (1997) combines western Hollywood crime, thriller, and noir tropes with themes that are specific to the post Soviet Russian experience.
            An important contextual historic fact is the Soviet film system heavily censored depictions of criminal acts in films produced in the Soviet Union. A film that depicts violent criminal acts was a novelty when Brother (1997) was produced.  The theme of western 
influence is portrayed several times in Brother (1997) two striking examples of the filmmaker commenting on western influences are instances of product placement. One of the films last scenes is an interior shot inside a McDonalds. Inside the McDonalds Danila has a final meeting with Kat. Normally in Russian literature in cinema the character of Kat would fulfill the archetype of the hooker with a heart of gold. Kat instead is tainted by western culture and is indifferent to Danila’s imminent departure from St. Petersburg. The other scene I found very striking in regards to the theme of western influence is the opening scene where Danila comes across a film production and is captivated.  In this scene we already have our first taste of western product placement where a bottle of 7up is depicted prominently in frame. Western values have already tainted Russian art. This idea is particularly interesting in s film that borrows so heavily from the west where the crime/thriller is a long established genre and the archetype of the anti-hero is long established.
            Some very Russian tropes are used in Brother (1997). The character of Kat would traditionally be the “hooker with the heart of gold” only she has been tainted by western values. During Danila’s final meeting with her she is indifferent to his leaving St. Petersburg more enthralled with her McDonalds cherry pie. Kat is not without manners and is truly grateful when he gifts her with a handful of cash as he leaves the McDonalds. Another trope found in the film that is seen in many soviet era films is the strong man or hero rising from the common folk to help his fellow man. We see this trope in early Russian films like Battleship Potempkin (1925) or Destiny of a Man (1959).
            Two films that share genre and thematic similarities with Brother (1997) are Death Wish (1974) and The Godfather (1972).  Thematically the idea of a weak and impotent society needing someone with the strength and will to take matters in his own hands are not only in Death Wish (1974) but many of the same story telling devices are used in both films to convey this theme. In both films the protagonist must protect the weak like the elderly and woman from the street crime that terrorizes them. The Godfather (1972) is an immigrant tale about family. At first blush Brother (1997) may not appear to deal with immigration but I believe the transition from the Soviet Union to the Russian Federation to be a type of immigration story. The citizens of Russia are changing regimes and shifting countries without taking a step or packing their bags. Much like Vito Corleone Danila must take the law into his own hands and commit crimes to make a livelihood for his family in an unfamiliar land and then later on much like Michael Corleone he must take the law into his own hands and commit crimes to protect his family.
            Two unfortunate specters attached to this film are the premature deaths of the star and director.  Sergei Bodrov Jr. who eventually began directing and producing in addition to his acting was killed in 2002 at the tragically young age of 30. While shooting his second film an ice block from the Djimara Mountain caused a rock/mud slide killing Sergei. The director of Brother (1997) Aleksei Oktyabrinovich died at the age of 54 in 2013 of a heart attack. During his career Oktyabrinovich directed sixteen films including the sequel to Brother (1997).  
            Russian cinema does not have a long tradition of the crime/thriller like Italian, American, or Japanese cinema. Brother (1997) is one of the most interesting things in cinema, a well established genre reinterpreted through the lens of a different culture. Aleksei Oktyabrinovich takes an established genre and elevates it much like Sergio Leone reinterpreted and elevated the western when it was considered a dead genre. Aleksei Oktyabrinovich combines western tropes and genres with Russian themes and issues like nationalism and national identity. Oktyabrinovich uses the crime thriller genre much like many film makers use science fiction. The action and tension of the film allows the filmmaker to couch heady topics like national identity in post Soviet Russia in a very accessible and palatable form. 

Tuesday, January 12, 2016

La Femme Nikita and the Death of French Cinema




           Luc Besson’s La Femme Nikita (1991) was a hit both in France and internationally upon its release in 1991. Despite its box office success and inspiring several iterations in both cinema and television La Femme Nikita (1991) received negative criticism. Expectations on what foreign films or French cinema should be influenced the negative criticism. French films that are distributed via the art house circuit internationally and in the United States have developed a certain reputation bordering on cliché in the decades since the French new wave shook and inspired the film world. Due to commercial considerations films need to classified and grouped. The distribution of French films is no exception. Despite the commercial necessity for being able to group and categorize films it can hurt the perception and reception of films that do not fit in categories or preconceived notions.
          Both for academic study and commercial distribution being able to group and categorize movies is beneficial. Both France and the United States have a long history with the motion picture. Both countries have individuals who can be credited as pioneers of cinema. Names like Thomas Edison and George Melies firmly entrench both countries in the development of the motion picture from attraction and amusement device to storytelling device to one of the most prominent mediums for storytelling consumption in the modern era.
          How do we define French cinema and how is it categorically different from traditional American or Hollywood cinema? How French film is perceived differently from American films is due largely to two factors. One factor is how movies are marketed and distributed both foreign and domestic. The second factor is France’s government subsidizing both French filmmakers and movie theatres that screen foreign and art house films. American films vary greatly but for the purposes of this paper American films will refer to Hollywood productions meant for wide theatrical release. French films that are distributed via the festival and art house circuit both domestically in France and internationally have a narrower audience then American films. Often times these audiences are educated consumers that one could call patrons of the arts. These audiences typically have no issue with films that require audience engagement or that are difficult to watch. An American film meant for a wide release will attempt to be a four quadrant movie. The four quadrants are the four main demographics movie studios want to appeal to in their attempts to have a blockbuster film. These four quadrants are men, woman, those under 25, and those older than 25. If an artist is not concerned with mass consumption they can be more specific in their vision and less compromising. Also it is more likely for filmmakers to make more experimental films and for theatres to specialize as art house theatres if the artists and theatre owners are receiving government support.
          ““La Femme Nikita” is shallow, glitzy, ultra-violent… the kind of foreign-language film that’s tailor made for people who want art and subtitles—the chic of it, the cachet—without the alleged pain or suffering of too many ideas or somber emotions.” (Wilmington 1991). This excerpt from a review from the Los Angeles Times helps highlight how American critics view what is French cinema. Given what French films typically make it to America is this review surprising? After decades of consuming French cinema what was once provocative and cutting edge has become first the norm and then what’s expected. A film like Hiroshima Mon Amour (1959) has come to be the cliché of what audiences in America have come to expect from French Cinema. An introspective character study that deals with emotion and psychology with an important historical backdrop that demands the audience to engage with the film to get the most out if it.
          When categorizing film two important distinctions that help clarify the difference between American cinema and French cinema are the terms first and second cinema. First cinema is your typical wide release Hollywood motion picture meant for wide conception. Typically these films employ continuity editing, 3 act structures, and meant to be immersive experiences where the audience suspends their disbelief. Amblin produced films such as Jurassic Park (1993) and E.T. (1982) are excellent examples of this ethos while being well made thoughtful films they are engrossing crowd pleasers. Steven Spielberg and Amblin Productions prove that art can still be accessible and great. Second cinema is films that are either foreign or independent films intended for a limited release. These films tend to screened on the festival circuit or in art house theatres. Because of their limited release these films can be more avant-garde in both craft and story. Films produced during the French new wave became famous for breaking the rules of continuity editing and ignoring the conventions of story structure.
          Tepid & negative reviews when La Femme Nikita (1991) was released were based on preconceived notions of what is and what is not French cinema. “Brainy French directors used to be acclaimed for elevating the look and structure of a movie over the content. But Besson’s ambitions are frankly commercial. He takes the “formalist” noodlings of an earlier generation of filmmakers and turns them into pop hooks, pumping up an absurdist thriller with lots of stylishly abstract atmosphere.” (Gleiberman 1991). Conventions and preconceived notions about the rules of visual storytelling are what the French new wave was rebelling against. Breaking the fourth wall and jump cuts must have been just as startling to movie goers and critics watching French films in the early 60’s as the intelligentsia was when they saw La Femme Nikita (1991) during its initial theatrical release.
          When one says I’m going to screen a French film to an American movie goer in 1991 a stylized, fast pace, action/spy film with a female lead isn’t what they would have guessed. During the French new wave it was commonplace for filmmakers to use pulp fiction like hardboiled detective stories as source material. One can draw a straight line from Luc Besson’s deconstruction of the action film in La Femme Nikita (1991) to what French filmmakers did decades earlier with film noir. French cinema has a long tradition of synthesizing and deconstructing American genres and motifs like gangster movies, film noir, and thrillers. Noted French filmmakers like Jean Pierre Melville and Francois Truffaut drew influence from American culture and genre literature & films. In 1991 an action movie with a female lead that passes the Bechtel test was not common place. La Femme Nikita (1991) is in the canon of French cinema because it deconstructs the action/spy genre by making the lead a strong female who by the conclusion takes agency over her future.
          La Femme Nikita (1991) has high production value and stylized editing that many associate with Hollywood. A French film that displays well crafted production values especially in the action scenes shouldn’t be seen as a negative. Shooting action well is an underrated craft in filmmaking. A kinetic action sequence can be like a violent ballet in the hands of filmmakers like Akira Kurosawa and John Woo. Action sequences are pure cinema with a lineage that can be traced back to the use of the slap stick and montage in silent film.
          The last decade of the twentieth century and the early twenty first century has seen the rise of the “international” filmmaker. This can be attributed to the growth of formal film education, home video, and the internet. Every year it becomes easier to share movies digitally and films that were once only seen by historians and preservationist can be viewed by the general populace via the internet or any one of the myriad of home movie mediums. Directors like Quentin Tarantino, Luc Besson, Bong Joon-ho, and Neil Blomkamp cinematic styles are less defined by the places they grew up but by the global genre films they consumed. It’s becoming harder to say a director has an Italian style or a Hong Kong style. La Femme Nikita (1991) was unfairly treated because Luc Besson was criticized by critics who said his style looks more American then French. Cinema has a cyclical nature of influence regarding American and foreign films. American film noir and pulp fiction influences the French new wave. The French new wave inspires the first generation of American film school directors like Coppola, Spielberg, and Scorsese. The Hollywood blockbuster influences Luc Besson and the snake continues to eat its own tail. “Besson may be the nearest French equivalent to the post-‘70s “movie brats”. He’s no thinker and he’s weak with character, he tends to ridicule or ignore literature, yet he works powerfully with the raw elements of movie-making.” (Wilmington 1991). The Los Angeles Times may not hold La Femme Nikita (1991) in as high esteem as I do but Mr. Hal Hinson does shares my observation of Luc Besson’s influences.
          The box office success of La Femme Nikita (1991) led to an American remake Point of No Return (1993) starring Danny Elfman’s better half Bridget Fonda. Despite being a shot for shot remake Point of No Return (1993) is the inferior film. The lack of success of Point of No Return (1993) both critically and financially shows La Femme Nikita (1991) is not another cliché action film that Hollywood churned during the 80’s and 90’s starring actors like Sylvester Stallone and Arnold Schwarzenegger.
          Do foreign films have to be ubiquitous with art house cinema? Visual storytelling is a versatile art form because it can be accessible and easy to understand and can be complex and demanding. Somewhere along the line complex and demanding became conflated with being superior to more accessible films. In the worlds of science and math the pinnacle achievement is finding simple and elegant answers to complex questions. Luc Besson was punished for having a stylized action packed film with a simple but emotionally powerful story. French cinema has always been stylized and emotionally powerful character driven films.
          The most powerful stories tend to be the simple ones recited over the centuries. The loner strolling into town to set right what has gone wrong or the farm boy finding his true destiny is to save the kingdom. “He seems to like playing off the generic, though he probably thinks of it as working with mythic, the classic. His sense of the mythic, though, is too impersonal to strike any deeper chords.” (Hinson 1991). Hal Hinson’s reductionist observation fails to realize that just because something is accessible it does not mean it is impersonal. Sometimes the most personal things are also the most relatable to audiences. Basic emotions like love and loss are cultural universals. If raw true emotion is expressed in such a manner that it is still fun and accessible to mass audience is it any less valid art then something esoteric that is only understood and appreciated by academics and intellectuals?  
          La Femme Nikita (1991) is the film that introduced Luc Besson to mainstream movie audiences around the world. Alfred Hitchcock said, “If it's a good movie, the sound could go off and the audience would still have a perfectly clear idea of what was going on.” Luc Besson makes such a film with La Femme Nikita (1991) that is both well crafted and strong visual storytelling. It is an emotional, thrilling, feminist, action film that is truly a piece of French cinema. Long live French cinema, viva la France!  


 Works Cited
Gleiberman, Owen. "La Femme Nikita." Entertainment Weekly , April 5, 1991: 2.
Hinson, Hal. "'La Femme Nikita'." The Washington Post, April 4, 1991: 2.
Wilmington, Michael. "Movie Review: 'Nikita': French Thriller With Feminine Twist." Los Angeles Times, April 12, 1991: 1.